The Dutton story stretches across generations and a lot of what happens in season one of 1923 directly connects to Taylor Sheridan's upcoming spinoffs 1944, The Madison, and of course, the acclaimed series, Yellowstone.
1923 sees the Dutton family's story defined by sacrifice, resilience and their unyielding determination to protect their land and legacy. From Spencer's exhausting journey back to Montana, to Teonna's harrowing life on the run and industrialists that threaten to dismantle the Yellowstone ranch, the storylines perfectly connect characters across time and also echo struggles that several generations of the Dutton family and Broken Rock Reservation natives have faced.
Below, we piece how Sheridan has connected the ending of season one of 1923 to storylines and characters across generations.
Read Next
Elizabeth's Miscarriage
By the end of first season of 1923, Elizabeth suffers a miscarriage. Jack gently suggests that perhaps her destiny isn't to have children of her own, but to care for someone else's. This mirrors Beth Dutton's storyline in Yellowstone — where she is unable to have children due to a life-altering decision made by Jamie without her consent. Later in the series, Beth essentially adopts a young boy named Carter, continuing the theme of motherhood taking unconventional forms, which is the case with Cara and Spencer.
Spencer's War Flashbacks
Spencer is haunted by vivid flashbacks from his time fighting in WWI, and trauma plays a large role in shaping his character. These flashbacks also foreshadow the upcoming spinoff series, 1944; having fought in WWI, before the events of 1923, it is entirely possible that Spencer may be called to serve again in WWII.
The Dutton's Financial Struggles
Financial hardship is a reoccurring challenge for the Dutton family in 1923. In Yellowstone, the family constantly battles to keep up with the rising taxes and overdue payments on the land. These same pressures exist in 1923, and by the end of the season, Whitfield sneakily pays off the Dutton ranch's tax debt, which put the family in debt to him. Similarly, the struggle of being in arrears is known all too well by John and Beth, who struggle to make payments in present day.
The Fight For Dutton Land
One of the longest-running struggles in the Dutton universe is the relentless fight to keep the Yellowstone ranch in the family. In 1923, that threat comes to a head when Donald Whitfield (a wealthy, evil mining tycoon) uses violence, manipulation, money and legal influence to take the Dutton land. He represents the beginning of new age industrialists who don't care for tradition and wish to use the land for business purposes.
In Yellowstone, it's a similar story as forces such as Dan Jenkins, the state government and market equities all pressure the Dutton family into selling their land or taking it by force. The Dutton family's fight for Yellowstone is ultimately one that sees them preserve their identity and way of life after fighting so hard to earn it.
Spencer Taking Over The Ranch/Journeying Back To Montana
One of 1923’s central threads is the need to pass the torch. As Jacob and Cara age, Spencer’s journey back to Montana symbolises the next chapter — and the great cost of inheriting the family destiny. This theme plays out again in Yellowstone, with John Dutton looking to Kayce, and wrestling with the heartbreak when the next generation hesitates or rebels.While little of The Madison is yet be revealed, we do know that it features a family from New York as they settle in the Madison River valley in central Montana. While we may not see their actual journey from New York to Montana, their journey may also be symbolic and represent duty, loyalty, and the commitment to family — similar to Spencer's voyage.
Teonna Escaping The Boarding School
A large part of season one saw Teonna Rainwater endure horrific abuse at an American Indian boarding school for girls, which causes her to kill two nuns and flee the school. Now on the run, her fight for survival is filled with danger and despair as she nearly gives up on several occasions.
While her fate in season two is still yet to unfold, it's likely that her determination and efforts led to the continuation of her family tree to live on. Ultimately, this leads to Chief Thomas Rainwater in Yellowstone. Like Teonna, Thomas carries the same resilience as her, as he is chairman of the Confederated Tribes of Broken Rock.
ELLE Collective is a new community of fashion, beauty and culture lovers. For access to exclusive content, events, inspiring advice from our Editors and industry experts, as well the opportunity to meet designers, thought-leaders and stylists, become a member today HERE.
